2.7 of 5 stars
Verified purchase
screenshot simulator
well ... friend gifted me a CD key because he couldn’t sell it. I didn’t plan to buy it myself — not only because Ubisoft’s attitude toward players is downright insulting, but also because I had a strong feeling the game would suffer from major design flaws. After actually playing it, I realized my decision not to buy it was absolutely right. === Pros The only good thing about this game — and I really mean the only thing — is its graphics and environmental design. The visuals are undeniably stunning, and the dynamic world-building and environmental detail are impressive. The terrain rendering and lighting system are top-notch, probably the best thing Ubisoft still knows how to do. The map feels alive, and visually it’s industry-leading, but that’s it. Everything else falls apart. === Cons 1. Awful parkour mechanics, terrible controls, and broken climbing detection I never imagined that after Assassin’s Creed Origins, Odyssey, and Valhalla, Shadows could feel like such a massive step backward — I literally laughed out loud in disbelief. The parkour feels heavy, clunky, and inconsistent. You constantly get stuck on random geometry, low fences inexplicably block your movement, and there’s no smooth auto-vault system for simple obstacles. Jumping between ledges often causes misdirection or failed inputs — your character simply doesn’t go where you intend. And the worst part? Most of this could’ve been automated. There’s no reason to mash jump and crouch repeatedly for actions that should be fluid. Playing as Naoe, the grapple mechanic is absurdly overcomplicated — you can’t just climb up or down intuitively; instead, you must toggle weird stances and manually adjust. Why not let W/S control swing and LMB/RMB handle climb and descend like a normal human system? Why overcomplicate everything? Even simple motions — like turning on a rope — involve unnecessary delays and micro-animations that kill the flow. And when dropping from rooftops, why does she have to do a pointless mid-air flip every time? It’s pretentious, adds zero value, and just makes the parkour feel sluggish and disconnected. Overall, Shadows’ parkour is a complete downgrade: the movement is sticky, inconsistent, full of pathing bugs, and plagued by pointless flourishes. What used to be elegant is now mechanical and broken — a hollow parody of what Assassin’s Creed used to mean. === 2. Idiotic combat design and meaningless complexity This is, without exaggeration, one of the most frustrating combat systems I’ve played since Rise of the Ronin. I can handle difficult combat — that’s not the issue. The issue is that this game’s combat is a chaotic, unbalanced mess. Enemies have random super armor, pointless “break” and “stack” states, and their AI behaves like caffeinated goblins — rolling and sidestepping erratically, with zero rhythm or logic. The collision detection and timing are all over the place. Parrying and dodging depend on frame-perfect inputs, yet enemy hitboxes often desync with their animations. Some attacks clip through your guard, others whiff through thin air. Enemies can instantly recover from guard breaks, and if you’re surrounded, you’re basically punished for engaging. The system forces you to play 1v1 mechanics in a 1v6 situation, with no reliable crowd control or spacing tools. Combat flow is a joke — the pace constantly breaks as enemies interrupt themselves mid-attack or freeze because your animation confused their logic. One moment they kick, the next they awkwardly reset their stance. It’s like watching bad motion-capture improv. Both playable characters feel unbalanced — one’s obviously better, making the other irrelevant. The skill trees and weapon types only amplify this imbalance rather than fix it. And variety? Forget it. Enemy move sets are barebones, repetitive, and predictable. You see the same three patterns recycled endlessly. It’s mind-numbingly dull: guard, break, slash twice, parry, roll, repeat. It’s not skillful; it’s mechanical exhaustion. If you wanted to copy For Honor’s combat rhythm, then actually learn from it. Right now, Shadows has the most inconsistent hit timing and worst tactile feedback I’ve ever seen in an AC title. There’s zero sense of impact — just floaty, delayed motions wrapped in bad sound design. This is what happens when a studio tries to “modernize” a franchise without understanding why its old systems worked. You get a Frankenstein’s monster of clunky mechanics, self-contradictory design, and fake complexity. ====== 3. Story logic and missing details Example: When Naoe is about to assassinate Wakasa. Wakasa is suspicious of Naoe, but still invites her home, turns his back, and starts giving philosophical speeches about destiny and ideals. Then he casually starts cleaning a gun while Naoe just picks it up and shoots him. Let’s unpack this: Why would a man who’s suspicious of her bring her home alone? Where’s his basic survival instinct? The gun is a display weapon. How does Naoe know it’s loaded? She doesn’t even check. She fires indoors — and somehow, no guards hear the shot. The streets are full of soldiers, yet no one reacts. Then she just walks away, completely unnoticed. That’s not “cinematic storytelling” — that’s lazy, careless writing. It destroys immersion and logic entirely. It’s like Ubisoft doesn’t even care about internal consistency anymore. Every major story beat feels stitched together purely for dramatic effect, with zero respect for narrative cohesion. === 4. Mission structure and design philosophy are broken Ubisoft clearly forced itself to shove every trendy mechanic imaginable into this game, and the result is a confused hybrid of conflicting systems. They tried to make missions more “open combat” — but that directly contradicts the stealth foundation of the series. So what’s the point of stealth anymore? You’re constantly pushed into loud, chaotic fights that undermine the assassin fantasy entirely. Remember Assassin’s Creed Unity and its multi-approach assassination planning? Gone. There’s no planning, no buildup, no payoff. You just barge in, stab, and escape — with zero tension or atmosphere. Most missions are formulaic to the extreme: infiltrate, loot, kill, escape, repeat. No creative setups, no evolving scenarios. It’s procedural and soulless. The series’ identity has collapsed — what was once a focused stealth-action experience has become a bloated open-world RPG stuffed with redundant systems. It’s no longer about precision or meaning, but about quantity and noise. Ubisoft has turned the series into a playground of meaningless “features” — a Frankenstein of RPG leveling, loot modifiers, clumsy combat, and broken stealth. They’ve buried what made Assassin’s Creed special beneath layers of corporate nonsense. ====== now i have deep respect for Joan of Arc — a soul of purity and conviction. But if Ubisoft keeps rewriting history this way, I half-expect them to twist even her story next: “Joan of Arc was secretly a Templar agent who oppressed peasants and was burned by an Assassin in disguise.” That’s exactly the kind of tone-deaf, lore-breaking nonsense this studio would do at this point. May Joan’s spirit remain pure and at peace — and may she look down upon what her people have become: a nation of hollow consumers, blind to thought, detached from meaning. === overall , assassins Creed Shadows has one thing going for it — the visuals. Everything else is dead on arrival. Combat is stiff, story is hollow, gameplay is pointless — a triple-layer disaster under a pretty shell. Ubisoft, every single person involved from top to bottom seems lost in a self-indulgent dream. You’re not creators, you’re pretend artists wearing diapers, pacifiers in mouth, imagining yourselves geniuses. If it weren’t for the blind loyalists you’ve trained to worship your work, no one would still care about this disgraceful mess.
moist
I really want to love and enjoy this game but it's just impossible. After pre-ordering and rage deleting i gave it another chance.. Start was somehow solid but playing at hardest difficulty is so painful due to encountering bug or other sh*t every fight, every damn thing you do. You want to use abilities? Nope sorry i won't work right now without reason. You want to dodge? Yes you can ofcourseeee but you see this 2cm high rock? Too bad now you are stuck and you will probably die. You want to fight with some inner calm? Okay you need milion squre miles for no camera glitch, dodge shit, roll stupidity and even then enemies locked in animation move/slide 3 more meters after your roll 'cause you're fucked and they just want to hit you. Heeey, did you tried our quicktime minigame? Yeeaaah? Fuck you! Shift+LMB will not work either! And things that worked at launch somehow magicaly stopped working.. congrats I know Shadows trying so hard to be skill based game but you know what? F*ck you Ubisoft. I have no problem paying for good game but did you even tried play your own game and see what are you making? What about testing and polishing .. i know CRAZY... For me THE best AC games are still Odyssey and Black Flag. Probably will be for ever 'cause my hopes for Ubi is lost and Shadows is last AC game i play and probably Ubisoft game too... Edit: Sooo i should start with something positive. Game looks really beautiful. Hideout can take a lot of time and makes you wanna buy all cosmetic sh*t, but that's probably all. Most of quests are painfully boring, quest log is bad and i mean really baaaaaaad. Sorting quests for specific location is non-existent. I am so sad i don't record by default 'cause bugs and eroors i encountered.. just wauuu. "Hit box" is retarded and enemies that missing you by meter still hit you. They can sometimes see ya at 50m through wall during blizzard, AI acting strange.. no problem chase you 500m shoot one arrow and than just turn around and don't give a shit. If you want to play this game play it on normal difficulty. You don't need take so serious approach in fights and just rip though them.
Device or other IDs
Location
The developer has not shared information about account and associated data deletion.
